Nikhil Gupta sentenced to 19 years in US over Pannun murder plot

A New York judge gave Nikhil Gupta 235 months in prison for the foiled plot to kill Gurpatwant Singh Pannun. What he said in court and where India stands.

Courtroom sketch of Nikhil Gupta at a federal court in New York
Image: Reuters via Al Jazeera

Nikhil Gupta, the Indian businessman who admitted plotting to have Sikh separatist leader Gurpatwant Singh Pannun killed in New York, has been sentenced to 235 months in a US prison, a little over 19 and a half years. US District Judge Victor Marrero handed down the sentence in Manhattan federal court on Friday, 20 November, and said Gupta will face deportation after serving it.

The man who was supposed to carry out the killing never existed: the “hitman” Gupta hired was an undercover US law enforcement officer.

What was Nikhil Gupta convicted of?

Gupta, 55, pleaded guilty in February to three charges: murder-for-hire, conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire, and conspiracy to commit money laundering. According to US prosecutors, an Indian government employee, named in the indictment as Vikash Yadav, recruited Gupta in 2023 to arrange Pannun’s killing. Prosecutors say Yadav agreed to pay $100,000 for the murder, and that $15,000 in cash was handed over as an advance to the undercover officer.

Pannun is a New York-based lawyer with US and Canadian citizenship who campaigns for a separate Sikh state, Khalistan. India has designated him a terrorist.

Gupta was arrested in Prague in June 2023 and extradited from the Czech Republic to the US in June 2024. He has been in custody without bail since.

What happened in court?

The hearing lasted about 80 minutes. Asked by the judge whether he wanted to withdraw his guilty plea, Gupta said no. In a statement of about six minutes he apologised: “I’m sorry to Mr Pannun, I’m sorry to the communities I hurt, I’m sorry to my own family.”

Prosecutors had asked for about 24 years. Prosecutor Ashley Nicolas told the court: “We don’t condone the use of violence to silence voices in this country, ever.”

Pannun was in the courtroom and spoke for about 20 minutes. He said he had not been able to return to his normal legal practice for more than 1,200 days since the plot came to light, called Gupta “just a foot soldier”, and accused India’s prime minister Narendra Modi of being behind it. That is Pannun’s claim; no court has found it.

What does India say?

India’s government denies any involvement and has said such a plot would be against its policy. After the US charges, India set up a high-level inquiry committee, which in January 2025 recommended legal action against one individual, without naming him publicly. Vikash Yadav is charged in the US case but is not in US custody, and India has not handed him over. There was no fresh statement from New Delhi on the sentence by Saturday morning.

Why it matters beyond India

The case is one of several that have strained India’s relations with the US and Canada, where India also denies claims of plots against Sikh activists. For Pakistan, which has long accused India of targeting people on foreign soil, the conviction of an Indian national in a US court is likely to be quoted often by officials in Islamabad.

The next question is Vikash Yadav: whether the US keeps pressing for him, and whether India’s own case against the official its inquiry named goes anywhere.

Read next