Ebenezer Scrooge: Johnny Depp's Christmas Carol gets split first reactions

Johnny Depp plays Ebenezer Scrooge in Ti West's film, out in US cinemas on 13 November. Critics love the gothic look but split on Depp himself.

Stylised promotional image of Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge
Image: Paramount Pictures

“Ebenezer Scrooge” is trending in Pakistan this week because Johnny Depp is playing him. Ebenezer: A Christmas Carol, directed by Ti West and released by Paramount, opens in US cinemas on Friday, 13 November, and the first reactions from critics are out. CNN called it Depp’s biggest role since his widely covered court battle with Amber Heard.

What the first reactions say

Variety’s round-up was mostly positive. One critic it quoted called the film a “wickedly fun holiday treat”, and others said it adds new layers to a story everyone thinks they know.

The Hollywood Reporter’s round-up was more mixed. Some praised a faithful, atmospheric and beautifully shot adaptation with a strong lead performance. Others felt it was a stylish gothic take with nothing new to say.

The split is sharpest over Depp. Some reviewers called him the perfect Scrooge; for others, his performance is the one part that does not work. Prediction market Kalshi even had traders betting on a “Rotten” Rotten Tomatoes score, which tells you how unsure people are.

Who else is in it

Ti West made his name with horror films (X, Pearl, MaXXXine), which explains the darker, gothic look. The cast includes Andrea Riseborough, Ian McKellen, Tramell Tillman from Severance, Rupert Grint and Daisy Ridley, according to the film’s Wikipedia listing.

Why it matters for Depp

This is Depp’s first big Hollywood studio lead in years. After the 2022 defamation trial against Amber Heard, he mostly worked on smaller and European projects, including Jeanne du Barry and directing Modi. A Christmas film from a major studio is a test of whether mainstream audiences will come back for him. CNN quoted him: “I’m not the man I was”, a line that fits both Scrooge and the actor’s own story.

Will it release in Pakistan?

No Pakistani release date has been announced. Hollywood holiday films usually reach Cinepax, Nueplex and Cinegold a week or two after the US, if distributors pick them up. Full reviews will land this week, and the opening-weekend box office on 15 November will show whether Depp’s comeback works.

Read next